During preparation of the treatment of the tribe Knoxieae for Flore d’Afrique centrale, we reassessed the broad circumscription of the genus Pentanisia proposed in the early 21st century. This delimitation appeared inconsistent with the aims of floristics, particularly the use of well diagnosable taxa. We therefore conducted a new molecular analysis of the Pentanisia clade and compared the subclades identified with morphological and biogeographical evidence. Verdcourt’s monograph of the 1950s, which divided Pentanisia into subgenera and sections and segregated Neopentanisia and Paraknoxia, proved largely congruent with our results. We propose to reinstate the genera Chlorochorion, Calanda, Neopentanisia, and Paraknoxia, restricting Pentanisia to Verdcourt’s subgenus Pentanisia and raising his subgenera Holocarpa and Ouranogyne to generic rank. Under this revised circumscription, all seven genera are monophyletic, with morphological support primarily derived from carpological characters.